Diligent Prosecution, Article II Challenges, and the Future of Environmental Citizen Suits
By:
Summary
At the end of 2025, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (“EPA”) issued a “Compliance First Policy” to direct its enforcement activities. This Policy signifies an express shift to favoring cooperative compliance assistance for regulated entities before the agency will target violations through formal enforcement and judicial avenues. However, seemingly anticipating that EPA’s shift to compliance over enforcement may lead to an uptick in environmental citizen suits, the Policy also emphasizes that EPA “must act swiftly to limit actions from third parties who, through citizen suit litigation, unfairly impact policy through abusive litigation tactics.”
Private parties have long relied on citizen suits as an alternative enforcement pathway under the major federal environmental statutes—including the Clean Air Act, Clean Water Act, Endangered Species Act, Resource Conservation and Recovery Act, and Toxic Substances Control Act. As the Supreme Court has underscored in the past, citizen suits supplement rather than supplant governmental action, and can typically proceed only when federal and state agencies do not exercise their enforcement responsibility.
The supplementary—rather than primary—role served by citizen suits is recognized by the statutory limits on when such suits may be brought. One of the notable limitations is the “diligent prosecution bar.” However, consistent with EPA’s recently announced policy indicating an interest in policing citizen suit litigation, the Department of Justice is acting to further limit the scope of citizen suit litigation in environmental matters. This shift is illustrated in a recent Clean Air Act citizen suit brought by the NAACP challenging compliance at xAI’s Colossus 2 data center. The United States moved to intervene in the case and argued that the government was authorized to unilaterally veto and dismiss citizen suits, even where the United States has chosen not to pursue prosecution of any alleged violations.
This Working Paper discusses: (i) how the diligent prosecution bar has historically been applied, (ii) how the United States is interpreting its ability to “swiftly” limit citizen suit actions in NAACP and NAACP Mississippi State Conference v. X.AI Corp. and MZX Tech LLC, No. 3:26-cv-00074-DMB-JMV (N.D. Miss.) (“NAACP”), and (iii) the potential bases for mounting constitutional challenges to citizen suit statutes arguing that such statutes infringe on the Executive Power and violate Article II.
Click HERE or on the PDF button above to read this Working Paper.
Authors
-
Tom Boer is a Partner with Hogan Lovells Cadwalader practicing in the firm’s San Francisco and Los Angeles offices. He serves as Global Co-Chair of the environmental practice. He previously served as a trial lawyer at the U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) Environmental Enforcement Section and in the Environmental Protection Agency’s (EPA) Office of General Counsel. Tom represents clients in federal and state environmental litigation, in defense of environmental enforcement actions and citizen suits, in response to catastrophic environmental emergencies and chemical releases, and in connection with site cleanup and cost recovery.
- Learn More
-
Kathy Vanderhook-Gomez is a Partner with Hogan Lovells Cadwalader and co-lead of the Chemical and Industrial Products Sector Group. She has unsurpassed expertise in environmental compliance and enforcement, drawing from her extensive experience across federal prosecution and corporate counsel roles. As a former federal environmental prosecutor and corporate environmental counsel, Kathy is well known at both the Department of Justice and Environmental Protection Agency and has deep experience in compliance counseling and civil litigation across federal and state environmental statutes.
- Learn More
-
Hayley Fink is Counsel to Hogan Lovells Cadwalader practicing in the firm’s Global Regulatory group. She advocates for clients on complex regulatory and litigation matters under a variety of environmental and energy laws. Hayley assists clients with regulatory compliance, permitting, internal investigations, and enforcement defense, and is experienced with the Clean Air Act, Clean Water Act, RCRA, FIFRA, and CERCLA. Prior to joining the firm, Hayley worked in private practice and clerked for the Honorable Anita B. Brody of the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania.
- Learn More